Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Hockey. The man who would be Treasurer... what can I say?

Eric Ellis of Euromoney magazine says it today in the National Times


Hockey needs more than Google for his economic research

Eric Ellis

Joe Hockey presents as a pleasant enough chap, in a matey, Billy Bunter type of way. But he needs help. The man who seems poised to hold Australia's economic future in his hands needs to try harder. At the least, he needs to read more extensively, more deeply and of a better quality of title. As does his researcher.

An excellent place to start would be within the annals of his own political hero and patron, John Howard.

In denigrating Euromoney magazine's awarding of its prestigious Finance Minister of the Year gong to Treasurer Wayne Swan, Hockey took particular relish at sticking it up the 2001 recipient, the then finance minister of Pakistan.

''In 2001 there was a Pakistani finance minister,'' Hockey incredulously informed Parliament. ''That is quite an extraordinary one, that one.''

One can't speak to what Hockey had in mind when he let fly that particular spray. His office refused to reveal what he found ''extraordinary'' about that gong to Pakistan. Maybe in Joe and his boss Tony's dog-whistling world, Pakistanis can't be capable of anything more than boarding a people-smuggler's rickety Australia-bound boat. Or perhaps strapping some explosives to their chest, or fixing a cricket match.

More likely, his research was no more scientific than googling Euromoney's Wikipedia pages, seeing the word Pakistan and thinking that will resonate in middle Australia as a synonym for basket case. And aren't they Muslims too? An electoral bonus in the heartland swing seats!

True, Pakistan isn't China (awarded in 2008) or Canada (last year, and a Tory too, inconveniently for Hockey). But had Joe browsed deeper he would have discovered the 2001 gong went to a man called Shaukat Aziz.

He would have discovered that Aziz was an expatriate career banker, at one point tipped to head Citibank in New York, when he was asked by Pakistan's president Pervez Musharraf to come home and fix the economy.

Aziz ushered in the most far-reaching program of economic reform in Pakistan since its 1947 independence, progress more profound than even the celebrated 1984 Keating reforms were for Australia.

Aziz later became prime minister, presiding over several boom years when Pakistan was second only to China in its buoyancy.

Under Aziz, Pakistan's economy doubled while the stockmarket and its foreign exchange reserves grew fivefold. Aziz stepped down in 2007, the first Pakistani PM to see out a full parliamentary term, some achievement in that difficult country. Now retired, he is a director of a big Singapore-based international hotel chain and the US private equity giant Blackstone.

Based on the economic evidence presented thus far, the Liberal member for North Sydney is a pygmy next to Aziz, and that's saying something. But all Joe really needed was to consult his political patron, John Howard, who knows Aziz well.

This was the gushing Howard, meeting Aziz in Islamabad on November 22, 2005. ''I'm impressed, if I may put it that way, Mr Prime Minister, with the great emphasis placed by your government, particularly under your leadership and with your business background, of the significance of economic growth and foreign investment,'' Howard said. ''Pakistan is winning herself a well-deserved reputation for being a country that beckons foreign investment and creates a transparent environment for foreign investment.''

As for the Nigerian recipient Hockey slagged, that's the Harvard-educated economist Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, who became finance minister in the second reformist term of Olusegun Obasanjo. On her watch Nigeria's economy roared...

Continued at the National Times



Related Posts

. Costings aftermath: Joe Hockey is to truth as....

. Hockey. Woolly on tax and costings

. Hockey reality check. Is $150,000 typical?

. That tirade against Joe Hockey at Menzies House

. Two of the likely candidates Tuesday are competent public administrators


8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Great response.

Shame it took so long for the response to emerge when it might have been able to counter Hockey's petulant display.

Anonymous said...

Priceless. It's a shame only the already informed will read it.

Kymbos.

Ralph said...

Agree with the other comments. Outstanding response. As much as I don't have any respect for Swanny, Joe's behaviour was poor form and he should have his nose rubbed in it.

Anonymous said...

Wollongong Wally said Abbott supports Bolt as he is guilty of a serious breach of the Racial Discrimination Act and Hockey shows his ignorance when he attacks a Pakistan Finance minister. And lets not mention their mate Cory Benardi ... something starting to smell

V said...

So how credible do you think Euromoneys awards are?

wilful said...

So how credible do you think Euromoneys awards are?

I'm sure you're trying to infer something, I'm just not sure what.

Bobalot said...

Joe Hockey's shameless ranting was outright racism. He only needed their nationality to dismiss their achievements rather than what they actually did.

It's little wonder that the Liberal party is known as the party of dog whistle racism.

V said...

@wilful

Infer this:
http://www.euromoney.com/Article/1042111/Title.html

http://www.euromoney.com/Article/1042121/Title.html

http://www.euromoney.com/Article/1042204/Title.html

Post a Comment

COMMENTS ARE CLOSED